Animas River
Insights
The Animas is really two rivers. It drops out of the San Juans above Silverton and runs south through Durango to New Mexico, and the fishing splits hard at the geography. Up high the water is beautiful and largely dead — a century of hardrock mining and acid drainage (the Bonita Peak Superfund district covers 48 sites in the upper tributaries) scoured roughly 60 miles of headwater of most trout. Fifty miles downstream through Durango it's a completely different fishery: a Gold Medal stretch of wide, boulder-strewn pocket water holding wild browns and rainbows that average 12–16 inches with fish to 20. This is city-limits fishing — the Gold Medal reach runs past a Home Depot and a Harley dealership with a paved bike path the whole way — but the trout don't care.
It fishes like a freestone, not a spring creek. The through-town water is nearly 100 feet wide with deep buckets, slick rock, and heavy current; the default game is weighted nymphs (caddis larva, stoneflies, midges) and sculpin streamers dredged through the seams, not delicate dry-fly work. It runs big and off-color during June snowmelt — high water out of a deep alpine snowpack blows it out most years into late June — then drops into shape by July and stays good through October. Winter is a legitimate season here: at 6,500 feet the in-town water rarely locks up, and midges plus the odd BWO carry December through February.
The elephant in the room is the August 2015 Gold King Mine spill — three million gallons of orange mine water that went viral worldwide. Worth being straight about it: there was no fish kill, not that day and not since. Metal concentrations spiked briefly in three non-game species and were back to pre-spill levels by the next sampling. Through Durango the plume was diluted and the trout came through it; the fishery today is healthy and CPW keeps the Gold Medal designation current. The real, ongoing constraint is the legacy acid mine drainage up top near Silverton, not the one-time spill — a headwaters problem, not a Durango one.
Species
- Brown Trout
- Rainbow Trout
- Brook Trout
- Colorado River Cutthroat Trout
- Smallmouth Bass
| Species | Abundance | Best Season | Size | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brown Trout | Primary | Sep-Nov | 12-18" | The dominant fish through town — wild, aggressive sculpin-eaters. Best on streamers in the fall pre-spawn. |
| Rainbow Trout | Common | Jun-Oct | 10-16" | Wild and supplemented, recovering from 1990s whirling disease via CPW's Hofer-strain genetic-resistance program. |
| Brook Trout | Present | Jul-Sep | 6-12" | Small-stream fish up high near Silverton and in feeder creeks. |
| Colorado River Cutthroat Trout | Rare | Jul-Sep | 8-14" | Native but very limited — persists in an unmined upper tributary, not a mainstem target. |
| Smallmouth Bass | Present | Jul-Aug | 8-14" | Shows up in the warmer, slower water below Durango toward the New Mexico line. |
Sections
Upper Animas — Silverton Headwaters (Howardsville to Silverton)
WadeCutthroat · Brook Trout · Rainbow Trout
Animas Canyon / Gorge — Train-Access Wilderness (Needleton to Tacoma)
WadeBrown Trout · Rainbow Trout
Bakers Bridge / Upper Animas Valley
WadeBrook Trout · Brown Trout · Rainbow Trout
Gold Medal Water — Through Durango (32nd Street to Rivera Bridge)
WadeBrown Trout · Rainbow Trout
Lower Animas — Below Durango to New Mexico (Southern Ute lands)
Wade & FloatBrown Trout · Rainbow Trout · Smallmouth
Regulations
The Gold Medal reach through Durango is artificial-flies-and-lures-only with a 2-fish, 16-inch minimum. Standard statewide Colorado trout rules apply elsewhere. Reservation reaches require a separate tribal permit.
Access & Logistics
Getting There
Durango, CO